maradydd: (Default)
maradydd ([personal profile] maradydd) wrote2009-02-07 02:42 am
Entry tags:

Drinking straw electrophoresis!

Gel electrophoresis is one of the most versatile, widely used tools in a microbiologist's or geneticist's toolbox. It's used for separating out DNA, RNA or protein molecules (that you presumably isolated in a previous step of your experiment) based on their molecular weight, so that you can analyze the molecules, clone them, amplify them with PCR, sequence them, lots of different things.

Electrophoresis does require some equipment to perform -- an inner tray which holds the gel, an outer tray which holds a "running buffer" solution (which keeps things cool and keeps pH stable), electrodes, and a power supply (50V-150V is pretty common). You can buy a gel box from a commercial supplier, though they're not cheap, and a fancy power supply will set you back even more; Bio-Rad has some nice ones, but they run to the thousands of dollars.

Happily, there are solutions for the biohacker on a budget. The University of Utah's genetics department has full specs for how to build your own gel box for about $25 in parts (not counting the power supply, which will run you about $50). The main components are clear acrylic and acrylic cement, which I purchased and had cut to size at TAP Plastics -- they also do mail order. My partner-in-science Tito Jankowski built one too, and did some test runs with food colouring which enabled him to separate the individual dyes which make up different colours. (The molecules in food colouring are pretty small, which is why the bands in Tito's video are a little smeary. He used agarose -- an edible, seaweed-derived polymer which you can find on the shelf in any Asian grocery store, also sold as "vegan gelatin" -- as his gel, and agarose is better suited to larger molecules like DNA. But it's definitely a proof of concept!)

Still, electrophoresis using large rectangular gels has some drawbacks. It's a bit messy, and in order to recover the particular band of DNA you want, you have to slice it out of the gel with a razor blade or something similar. Cleaning up the equipment is also a bit of a pain. If you're using acrylamide or polyacrylamide (common for protein electrophoresis), you need to find a safe way to get the used gel out of the gel carrier and dispose of it properly. Also, while DNA electrophoresis is run horizontally, protein electrophoresis is done vertically, so that means two different pieces of equipment.

This was a recent topic of discussion on the DIYbio mailing list. Ben Lipkowitz wondered whether it would be possible to use a narrow, rigid tube to contain the gel, rather than a big carrier. This would allow for the use of less buffer and lower voltage, since a physically smaller amount of gel is a smaller resistor.

Well, what's a narrow rigid tube that's easy for anyone to acquire? A clear drinking straw! Paper clips make for appropriately sized electrodes, and since a drinking straw is rigid, it can be used in either the horizontal or the vertical orientation. For extra bonus points, when you're ready to cut a band out of the gel, no need for mucking around with razor blades -- just take a (sterile) pair of scissors, snip snip, and you're done! Plus, disposal is extra simple, even with polyacrylamide -- just dispose of the entire straw, gel and all, properly.

Tito Jankowski tried this out, using a single 9V battery as a power supply, and after some debugging, it worked beautifully. (He also used alligator clips as electrodes, and they worked just fine.) We're calling these "keiki gels" because they're so small and cute -- and so simple, even a little kid can do them.

This is crowdsourced science at its very finest. Behold the power of collaboration!

Tito's keiki gels!


ETA: Tito wrote a protocol, doo dah, doo dah
soon_lee: Image of yeast (Saccharomyces) cells (Default)

Re: crazy straws...

[personal profile] soon_lee 2009-02-08 09:03 am (UTC)(link)
Proof of principle in SCIENCE (published at start of the year). The realtime movie in supplemental materials is awesome.

(Here via BoingBoing)
soon_lee: Image of yeast (Saccharomyces) cells (Default)

[personal profile] soon_lee 2009-02-08 09:13 am (UTC)(link)
My boss remembers a time before commercially available restriction enzymes when they had to isolate their own. And it wasn't *that* long ago.

Of course, some source organisms will be less hazardous to grow than others: EcoRI vs. HindIII for example.

[identity profile] nativeprincess.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 06:18 pm (UTC)(link)
Straw electrophoresis....best thing ever.
Down side seems to be that you can't run it next to a ladder for comparison. You could do that in a separate straw but that's not going to be under identical conditions. More than likely its close enough, but have you thought of ways to get around this issue and still use the straw concept?

Re: crazy straws...

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Sweet! It's on the to-read list for the week (no access to Science at home, alas).

Re: imaging

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Definitely worth a shot! I'll pass that on to Tito.

Re: !/2 filled straw....horizontal..cutting..

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:38 pm (UTC)(link)
*facepalm* You're absolutely right! I haven't done any serious sewing in forever, but I still have a couple of those in my box o' tricks. Thanks for the suggestion!

Crowdsourced science really is the best thing ever.

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:38 pm (UTC)(link)
No, thank you! If they tell you how well it worked, I look forward to hearing about it. :)

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:39 pm (UTC)(link)
We've got some folks on the DIYbio list with hands-on experience in doing exactly that, FYI. Feel free to come ask questions, diybio@googlegroups.com.

Re: Slightly off-topic but...

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:40 pm (UTC)(link)
Nope, you're definitely not the only one. It pops up whether I want it to or not. *grin*

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis - Removal Method

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:41 pm (UTC)(link)
I don't know off the top of my head, but given that both plasmids and linear DNA are often stored at -4C, I reckon it wouldn't hurt the bands at all. Thanks!

Great quote

(Anonymous) 2009-02-08 08:49 pm (UTC)(link)
I just re-read that book last night! AND great work here. Fantastic!

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:51 pm (UTC)(link)
Well, here's the thing. When we do electrophoresis in a rectangular gel with multiple wells, the gel behaves (electrically) as a single, fairly high-valued resistor. This allows us to be confident that each well is being exposed to the same amount of current (which is basically "motive force", in electrical terms) and that the molecules travel at the same rate.

Now, when I was building radios and antennas, we sometimes had to worry about impedance matching (which is fundamentally resistance-matching) in cables. Two lengths of cable (or any other material that has the same resistance per unit length) that are of identical length will have identical impedance. So I'm pretty sure that two gel-filled straws of identical length will also have identical resistance.

Putting two gel-filled straws of identical length in the same bath and running current through it is equivalent to putting two resistors in parallel, and by Ohm's law we know that when we put N identical resistors in parallel, each resistor draws the same amount of current. (The math has a lot of fractions in it and isn't easy to demonstrate in HTML, but it's easy to find if you google "resistors in parallel".) Thus, my hypothesis is that if one uses straws of identical length, and put the DNA into each straw at the same point, the DNA will migrate down the gel at the same rate.

We plan to test this in the near future by running, say, five keiki gels all containing identical molecular weight marker samples at the same time. If they produce the same ladders, then (modulo repeating this a number of times to make damn certain it wasn't an anomaly, of course, and repeating it with different types of DNA ladder) I think we can be pretty confident that we will be able to run a sample of interest in one straw and a DNA ladder in another straw, provided that both straws are of the same length and samples are loaded at the same point in the gel.

I haven't put a whole lot of thought yet into how we'll get around this if my hypothesis proves false, but one thing at a time. :)
Edited 2009-02-09 01:09 (UTC)

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis!

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Wow, can you point me to that $200 power supply? I have a (broken, needs a hard-to-find transistor replaced) Bio-Rad power supply lying around which lists at $6K -- though it has a whole lot of fancy features like the ability to do timed runs, the ability to do two different runs simultaneously, and so on and so forth.

Re your #2, what do you think about my comment to [livejournal.com profile] nativeprincess below?

I did not know about #3, that's good to know. (Haven't done any wet lab protein work yet.) Do you know if they'll set up properly in, say, a CO2 atmosphere?

FWIW, the folks working on the Open Gel Box 2.0 (details available on openwetware.org) have sourced platinum wire at reasonable expense for just that reason.
Edited 2009-02-08 20:55 (UTC)

Re: Great quote

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 08:56 pm (UTC)(link)
Thanks!

[identity profile] renwick.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 09:08 pm (UTC)(link)
Thanks! I just joined.

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-08 10:42 pm (UTC)(link)
Great, glad to have you on board!

It's also not hard to buy your own (http://www.fermentas.com/catalog/re/index.html), though I for one want to know how to do it myself just for the sheer fun of knowing how to do it.

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-09 01:24 am (UTC)(link)
I use the 5V and 12V rails from PSUs as quick-and-dirty power supplies all the time, though hadn't thought about the voltage step up circuit. By what ratio do they typically raise the voltage? Junked printers are easy to find.
ext_74: Baron Samadai in cat form (Default)

[identity profile] siliconshaman.livejournal.com 2009-02-09 01:46 am (UTC)(link)
Depends on the printer, but I think the typical heater voltage is between 50 to 150volts. I.e, right in the range needed. [which is why I thought of it.] Starting from 12volts input.
Edited 2009-02-09 01:49 (UTC)

[identity profile] maradydd.livejournal.com 2009-02-09 01:51 am (UTC)(link)
Badass. I'll pass this on to the guys working on the power supply for the Open Gel Box 2.0. Thanks!

Agar vs. agarose

(Anonymous) 2009-02-09 02:35 am (UTC)(link)
Not one to nitpick (oh, hell, yes I am...) but I think the kind of polymer you can get at the grocery is agar, rather than agarose. :)

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis!

(Anonymous) 2009-02-09 05:19 am (UTC)(link)
Sorry I'm anonymous - no lj account.

re1. Depending upon the diameter of the straw a wire stripper works well to cut the straw from around the gel.

re 2. I completely agree with the slab gel comments. Slab gels are much better. we tried these straw gels (our lab referred to them as "macro-capillaries") in the early 90's and although I still occasionally use them for prep work, the results always seemed to be smeary, which we guessed was due to charge distribution. Besides, you can make perfectly acceptable slab gels with microscope slides(or any other flat piece of glass - thicker is better), 1" lab tape, two bulldog clips and a piece of carved delrin or similar plastic for the comb. If memory serves correctly this was eventually published in the early maniatis molecular cloning book. Because we didn't have a lot of grant money in the early days - 1980ish, we used these mini slab gels for at least five years and got publishable results. the mini slab gels are especially good because you use very little agarose which in those days was pretty expensive (still not all that cheap).I still use them sometimes even though we have grant money. Also with a model train transformer and a multimeter you can most definitely have a cheap electrophoresis setup, just keep an eye on the current every once in a while, as that tends to shift when the buffer ph changes during the run.

re 5. I can't disagree more. Due to experience introducing high school students to molecular biology, I have made many a gel box from tupperware boxes, a little "shoogoo" which I'm guessing is a type of silicon cement (I'm too cheap to buy new tennis shoes when all I've worn out is the sole, so I usually have that lying around) and NICKEL wire - not platinum! nickel works fine. (of course platinum is optimal, but not everyone needs to drive a lexus.) also a couple alligator clips, you don't even have to use the build-it-yourself utah site which to me seems to be a whole lot of work for very little increase in function. If you can find some cheap nickel wire (or share a spool) you can build a box for under $5. Steal two bulldog clips from your office. I'm not sure why I'd need high "precision" or reproduceablilty if I have a ladder for size comparison on a slab gel or if I'm just running a prep gel which is about 99% of what people use electrophoresis for. Unless you are doing some sort of specialized electrophoresis like pulsed gel, or higher voltage for polyacrylamide gels, there is no reason to spend $1000 on electrophoresis setup when you can get the SAME results for less than $50. Try setting up 20 dna stations for high school students given a typical summer program budget. the reason you pay $1000 is because that is what fisher thinks you can pay for it. All of the expensive equipment which we pay $1000's for all started out as someone's DIY project.

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis!

(Anonymous) 2009-02-09 05:24 am (UTC)(link)
Low cost PS is, for example, BioRad cat #165-5048, PowerPac Mini Power Supply, 100 or 200 V, List Price: $252.00. Biorad and other companies often have "educational" kits that can save a lot of time and money too.

About your comment for #2: the general idea is correct. The voltage and time should be the same for all samples. In reality, other parameters should be the same too, e.g. temperature. If you run the gel "hot", often the front of the dye will not be straight, but curved with faster zone in the middle. This is due to heating up of the gel and greater heat exchange closer to the border (end) of the gel. Actually, in the case of PAGE gels, sometimes you can see DNA melting due to this.

The PAGE gel should polymerize in CO2, but why bother? Besides, regular CO2 atmosphere commonly found in tissue culture labs is actually just 5% CO2 in air. If you are going through the effort of setting up O2-free atmosphere, use nitrogen or argon. But then again, why bother?

For home use, metals other than platinum should be fine. I would imaging that silver or gold can do the trick. Expense will be much smaller, especially if one coats say copper wire with silver or gold. Silver nitrate used to be sold in pharmacies, not sure if one still can buy it.

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis - Removal Method

(Anonymous) 2009-02-09 05:27 am (UTC)(link)
the temperature you store DNA at will depend upon the buffer and what you want to use it for. If you have long genomic DNA and want to use it for southern blots, so you don't want to shear it by freezing, you store it at 4C (the fridge) in a buffer like TE to prevent hydrolysis. If it has to be in plain water, ie, because you are pcring it and don't want the EDTA messing up your Mg ion concentration, you store it at -20 (the freezer). In fact most of the time it is stored at -20 if it is solution. If it is plasmid you can dry it and store it at room temp.

Re: Drinking straw electrophoresis!

(Anonymous) 2009-02-09 05:37 am (UTC)(link)
re5. Depends on application. For the applications you have listed (running a prep gel or a quick check to see if DNA was digested) I also do not use $1000 power supply. But, as you said, for "special" applications I would use it. For $1000 one can get a high voltage PS, something you need to run long gel, or pulsed field gel. Lately, I have actually switched from running gels to using a chip-based system (Experion) from BioRad to analyse proteins, DNA and RNA. The system is based on capillary electrophoresis, but provides a lot more data at a shorter time.

Of course, I would not setup asummer program for students using $1000 power supplies. DIY setup with a transformer to give ~ 50V and a simple bridge rectifier is sufficient. I would also add a fuse and try to run these from a GFI outlet. High-school students are too curious sometimes for their own good ( I've been in high school too some 30 yr ago).



Re: !/2 filled straw....horizontal..cutting..

[identity profile] keith-m043.livejournal.com 2009-02-09 06:09 am (UTC)(link)
It seems to me that the 'thumb' of the seam ripper would leave a trail of displaced molecules behind it when making the cut. Perhaps this effect is negligible if you cut down the column rather than up.

I think what I would do is freeze the straw solid and either slit the straw lightly with razor blade or use a dowel to push the column out the end.

Side note: for a thicker column, there are these straws used with 'bubble teas' in chinese restaurants. Presumably they are still relatively cheap, albeit a bit more difficult to find than grocery store straws

Page 3 of 5